1) MP -> Attach MIDI controller
2) Click on MSF knob
3) Move MIDI controller knob
Result: nothing happens (controller number registered in 'MIDI Settings' window)
4) Click with the mouse on the MSF knob
5) Move MIDI controller knob
Result: nothing happens
6) Click with the mouse on the MSF knob, AND turn the knob
7) Move MIDI controller knob
Result: Assignment is made.
Note: IMHO there should not be a need to wiggle the knob with the mouse for this to work.
MSF bug: MIDI assign of a MP - have to mouse click _and_ turn the knob
-
- KVRAF
- Topic Starter
- 3644 posts since 3 Nov, 2015
-
MeldaProduction MeldaProduction https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=176122 - KVRAF
- 14019 posts since 15 Mar, 2008 from Czech republic
So it's more like a FR than a bug, right? 
I'm not sure this will be possible to fix, but I'll check.
I'm not sure this will be possible to fix, but I'll check.
-
MeldaProduction MeldaProduction https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=176122
- KVRAF
- 14019 posts since 15 Mar, 2008 from Czech republic
Hmm, so change of plans, it actually works here. What OS and host are you using?
-
- KVRAF
- Topic Starter
- 3644 posts since 3 Nov, 2015
I tried it again several times, at times restarting the DAW for having a clean slate. The MIDI keyboard is an Axiom 25.
Only mouse-clicking on a MSF knob, w/o wiggling it, does not start the actual MIDI recognition of hardware MIDI messages. What it does in this case is, when wanting to assign the OSC -> SHAPE -> Shape knob:
1) Turning the mouse cursor to a vertical double headed arrow.
2) Showing the MIDI control number as various hardware controller knobs are turned. Eg.
Controller: Utility 058
Controller: Utility 059
Controller: Utility 053
3) The previously assigned MSF knob is turning with each different hardware controller knob. The same MSF knob, in this case OSC -> SHAPE -> Custom is turning when hardware knobs 058, 059 and 063 are turned. 'Custom' was previously assigned to Utility 054.
So far what I see is that a MSF knob has to be mouse-clicked and wiggled - after clicking on 'Learn' - for the MIDI learning to really start and the hardware MIDI knob to be assigned.
Following on the steps described above:
4) Clicking on OSC -> SHAPE -> Shape and wiggling that MSF knob just a tiny bit seemed to 'wake up' the recognition and only then a new hardware controller can be assigned.
The host is Bitwig 2.4.3. MPE is disabled (if it has anything to do with MIDI messages in the case, same behaviour when enabled though).
If it really has to do with the OS, then forget it as I'm running Linux (Xubuntu 18.04 LTS, wine-4.5 (Staging), linvst from git with added patch for Melda plugins circa January 2019)
No need to say that MIDI works very fine in Linux, with all DAWs and plugins, native Linux and Windows-based.
Cheers.
Only mouse-clicking on a MSF knob, w/o wiggling it, does not start the actual MIDI recognition of hardware MIDI messages. What it does in this case is, when wanting to assign the OSC -> SHAPE -> Shape knob:
1) Turning the mouse cursor to a vertical double headed arrow.
2) Showing the MIDI control number as various hardware controller knobs are turned. Eg.
Controller: Utility 058
Controller: Utility 059
Controller: Utility 053
3) The previously assigned MSF knob is turning with each different hardware controller knob. The same MSF knob, in this case OSC -> SHAPE -> Custom is turning when hardware knobs 058, 059 and 063 are turned. 'Custom' was previously assigned to Utility 054.
So far what I see is that a MSF knob has to be mouse-clicked and wiggled - after clicking on 'Learn' - for the MIDI learning to really start and the hardware MIDI knob to be assigned.
Following on the steps described above:
4) Clicking on OSC -> SHAPE -> Shape and wiggling that MSF knob just a tiny bit seemed to 'wake up' the recognition and only then a new hardware controller can be assigned.
The host is Bitwig 2.4.3. MPE is disabled (if it has anything to do with MIDI messages in the case, same behaviour when enabled though).
If it really has to do with the OS, then forget it as I'm running Linux (Xubuntu 18.04 LTS, wine-4.5 (Staging), linvst from git with added patch for Melda plugins circa January 2019)
No need to say that MIDI works very fine in Linux, with all DAWs and plugins, native Linux and Windows-based.
Cheers.
-
MeldaProduction MeldaProduction https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=176122
- KVRAF
- 14019 posts since 15 Mar, 2008 from Czech republic
Well I fear it can be linux indeed. Anyways please if possible make a video and send it to me via info@meldaproduction.com. I'll try to replicate your actions and we'll see. But please wait for 13.01 first just in case 
